Agnes B Wins Trademark Opposition in Taiwan

In a trademark opposition filed by Agnes B, Taiwan’s IP Office (“TIPO”) ruled in favor of the French fashion brand, finding the contested trademark, which features a cursive “l” letter, to be too similar to Agnes B’s iconic “b” signatures (no. 00864444, no. 00542007, no. 00820058, and no. 01471708, see below).

The contested trademark, no. 02335495 (see below), was filed by LOVFEE, a Taiwan-based apparel brand on May 4, 2023, and was granted on November 16, 2023. It was registered in Class 25, covering various kinds of clothing and accessories, such as coats, sweaters, skirts, hats, T-shirts, scarves, etc. Agnes B filed opposition on January 15, 2024, citing violations of Articles 30.1.10, 30.1.11, and 30.1.12 of Trademark Act.

TIPO ruled in Agnes B’s favor on May 29, 2025 based on Article 30.1.10, reasoning that:

1.        Article 30.1.10 of Trademark Act provides that a mark shall not be registered if such a mark is similar to another’s registered trademark, is applied for use on similar products or services, and is likely to cause confusion among the relevant consumers. 

2.        On similarity of the trademark, the contested trademark consisted of a cursive letter “l” and a “heart” icon. Agnes B’s cited trademarks featured a cursive letter “b”. When comparing the overall style and structure, the cursive letter “l” bears visual similarity with the stylized “b” logo, which constitutes the dominant portion of Agnes B’s trademarks. The way the cursive “l” was written, such as the style and contour of its curve, closely resembles Agnes B’s “b” signatures. 

3.        On similarity of the product, the cited trademarks were also designated for use in Class 25 (including apparel, shoes, and accessories such as belts, hats); and in Class 35 (including the retails services for clothing, shoes, and other accessories). The scope of the designated products of the contested trademark overlaps with those covered by Agnes B’s “b” signatures. 

4.        Moreover, Agnes B’s cited trademarks are inherently distinctive. Based on evidence of continuous trademark use throughout the period of 2011-2023, the iconic “b” signatures have become well-known in the relevant consumers in Taiwan. In fact, the well-known status of the “b” signatures has been reviewed and consistently confirmed in other trademarks oppositions. Therefore, consumers should be more familiar with Agnes B’s trademarks.

In view of the above, given the similarity between Agnes B’s and LOVFEE’s trademarks, the overlap of the designated products, and the high distinctiveness and strong brand recognition of Agnes B’s “b” signatures, TIPO concluded that the registration of LOVFEE’s contested trademark may cause confusion. Thus, the contested trademark was cancelled accordingly.

 

Source: https://cloud.tipo.gov.tw/S282/S282WV1/#/written-result-details/disposition?issueKey=doNRI%2BOhBsYWoPtrYyQmZodywSs1Dr26Tofw