Taiwan’s IP Office Sides with TWG Tea in Trademark Dispute

On May 1, 2025, Taiwan’s IP Office (“TIPO”) ruled in the favor of popular tea brand TWG Tea, finding the contested trademark, although designated for use in different product categories, may still cause confusion with the well-known “TWG” trademarks (See below).

The contested trademark, “TWG” (no. 02410921, see below), was filed on April 21, 2024, and granted on November 1, 2024, covering products in Class 3, including facial cleansers, bath gel, soap, shampoo, hair conditioners, facial cream, lipsticks, body lotion, skin care products, etc. TWG TEA filed opposition on January 24, 2025, citing, among other grounds, violation of Article 30.1.11 of Trademark Act.

TIPO ruled in TWG Tea’s favor based on the following reasons:

1.      Article 30.1.11 of Trademark Act provides that a mark shall not be registered if such a mark is being identical with or similar to another person’s well-known trademark or mark, and hence there exists a likelihood of confusion on the relevant public or a likelihood of dilution of the distinctiveness or reputation of the said well-known trademark or mark.

2.      Here, based on the submitted evidence, including the development of physical stores in Taiwan, worldwide trademark registrations of “TWG”, and the continuous and ongoing media exposure and marketing between 2009 and 2020, including the joint campaigns with other cosmetic brands like Shiseido, TIPO affirmed that TWG Tea’s “TWG” trademarks had become well-known in the fields of tea, tea drinks, and relevant beverage services before the filing date of the contested trademark. On the other hand, given that the registrant of the contested trademark did not submit any evidence of use, TIPO considered the consumers are more familiar with TWG Tea’s trademarks.

3.      TIPO noted that the contested trademark consisted of the letters “TWG”, which are identical to the dominant wording in TEA TWG’s cited trademarks. It is evident that the contested trademark is highly similar to TWG Tea’s famous “TWG” trademarks.

4.      Although the contested trademark was designated for use in different product categories, TIPO observed that, in addition to relevant products like teapots, tea trays, and tea spoons, there were records showing that TWG Tea had collaborated with other cosmetic brands to promote products like fragrances, essences, and skin care items. Thus, TWG Tea is likely to expand its brand into cosmetic products.

5.      In view of the well-known status of “TWG”, the high degree of similarity, the familiarity of TWG Tea’s brand, and the diversification of merchandise, TIPO concluded that the contested trademark, even though designated for cosmetic products, may still cause confusion with TWG Tea’s famous trademarks. Thus, the contested trademark was canceled accordingly.

 

Source: https://cloud.tipo.gov.tw/S282/S282WV1/#/written-result-details/disposition?issueKey=doNRI%2BOhAc4QpvuDYGofCIPD1Q0MnIie8SsY